[#MAVEN-1501] maven seems not to evaluate .properties of parent pom - jira.codehaus.org

Details

Type: Bug
Status: Closed
Priority: Major
Resolution: Fixed
Affects Version/s: 1.0.1
Fix Version/s: 1.0.2
Component/s: core
Labels:
None
Environment:

Hide
[][9.2.0](10)> maven -i
__ __
| \/ |__ _Apache__ ___
| |\/| / _` \ V / -_) ' \ ~ intelligent projects ~
|_| |_\__,_|\_/\___|_||_| v. 1.0.1

#---- BEGIN: Which report
Which.version=Which.java:($Revision: 1.2 $) WhichJar.java:($Revision: 1.2 $)
java.version=1.4.1_06
file.encoding=ISO646-US
java.ext.dirs=/usr/j2se/jre/lib/ext
java.class.path=/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/forehead-1.0-beta-5.jar
os.name=SunOS
java.vendor=Sun Microsystems Inc.
sun.boot.class.path=/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/endorsed/xerces-2.4.0.jar:/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/endorsed/xml-apis-1.0.b2.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/rt.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/i18n.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/sunrsasign.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/jsse.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/jce.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/charsets.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/classes
java.runtime.name=Java(TM) 2 Runtime Environment, Standard Edition
#---- END: Which report

Installed plugins:
  maven-abbot-plugin-1.1
  maven-announcement-plugin-1.3
  maven-ant-plugin-1.8.1
  maven-antlr-plugin-1.2.1
  maven-appserver-plugin-2.0
  maven-artifact-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-ashkelon-plugin-1.2
  maven-aspectj-plugin-3.2
  maven-aspectwerkz-plugin-1.2
  maven-caller-plugin-1.1
  maven-castor-plugin-1.2
  maven-changelog-plugin-1.7.1
  maven-changes-plugin-1.5.1
  maven-checkstyle-plugin-2.5
  maven-clean-plugin-1.3
  maven-clover-plugin-1.6
  maven-console-plugin-1.1
  maven-cruisecontrol-plugin-1.5
  maven-dashboard-plugin-1.5
  maven-developer-activity-plugin-1.5.1
  maven-dist-plugin-1.6.1
  maven-docbook-plugin-1.2
  maven-ear-plugin-1.5
  maven-eclipse-plugin-1.9
  maven-ejb-plugin-1.5
  maven-faq-plugin-1.4
  maven-file-activity-plugin-1.5.1
  maven-genapp-plugin-2.2
  maven-gump-plugin-1.4
  maven-hibernate-plugin-1.2
  maven-html2xdoc-plugin-1.3.1
  maven-idea-plugin-1.5
  maven-j2ee-plugin-1.5.1
  maven-jalopy-plugin-1.3.1
  maven-jar-plugin-1.6.1
  maven-java-plugin-1.4
  maven-javacc-plugin-1.1
  maven-javadoc-plugin-1.7
  maven-jboss-plugin-1.5
  maven-jbuilder-plugin-1.5
  maven-jcoverage-plugin-1.0.9
  maven-jdee-plugin-1.1
  maven-jdepend-plugin-1.5
  maven-jdeveloper-plugin-1.4
  maven-jdiff-plugin-1.4
  maven-jellydoc-plugin-1.3.1
  maven-jetty-plugin-1.1
  maven-jira-plugin-1.1.2
  maven-jnlp-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-junit-doclet-plugin-1.2
  maven-junit-report-plugin-1.5
  maven-jxr-plugin-1.4.2
  maven-latex-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-latka-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-license-plugin-1.2
  maven-linkcheck-plugin-1.3.3
  maven-multichanges-plugin-1.1
  maven-multiproject-plugin-1.3.1
  maven-native-plugin-1.1
  maven-nsis-plugin-1.1
  maven-pdf-plugin-2.2.1
  maven-plugin-plugin-1.5.2
  maven-pmd-plugin-1.6
  maven-pom-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-rar-plugin-1.0
  maven-release-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-repository-plugin-1.2
  maven-scm-plugin-1.4.1
  maven-shell-plugin-1.1
  maven-simian-plugin-1.4
  maven-site-plugin-1.5.2
  maven-struts-plugin-1.3
  maven-tasklist-plugin-2.3
  maven-test-plugin-1.6.2
  maven-tjdo-plugin-1.0.0
  maven-uberjar-plugin-1.2
  maven-vdoclet-plugin-1.2
  maven-war-plugin-1.6.1
  maven-webserver-plugin-2.0
  maven-wizard-plugin-1.1
  maven-xdoc-plugin-1.8
Home Build properties: {maven.build.dir=/home/tminor/maven/build/${pom.groupID}/${pom.artifactId}, build.view.path=/mms, maven.home.local=/home/tminor/maven/localhome}

Show
[][9.2.0](10)> maven -i __ __ | \/ |__ _Apache__ ___ | |\/| / _` \ V / -_) ' \ ~ intelligent projects ~ |_| |_\__,_|\_/\___|_||_| v. 1.0.1 #---- BEGIN: Which report Which.version=Which.java:($Revision: 1.2 $) WhichJar.java:($Revision: 1.2 $) java.version=1.4.1_06 file.encoding=ISO646-US java.ext.dirs=/usr/j2se/jre/lib/ext java.class.path=/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/forehead-1.0-beta-5.jar os.name=SunOS java.vendor=Sun Microsystems Inc. sun.boot.class.path=/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/endorsed/xerces-2.4.0.jar:/home/tminor/maven-1.0.1/lib/endorsed/xml-apis-1.0.b2.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/rt.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/i18n.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/sunrsasign.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/jsse.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/jce.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/lib/charsets.jar:/usr/j2se/jre/classes java.runtime.name=Java(TM) 2 Runtime Environment, Standard Edition #---- END: Which report Installed plugins:   maven-abbot-plugin-1.1   maven-announcement-plugin-1.3   maven-ant-plugin-1.8.1   maven-antlr-plugin-1.2.1   maven-appserver-plugin-2.0   maven-artifact-plugin-1.4.1   maven-ashkelon-plugin-1.2   maven-aspectj-plugin-3.2   maven-aspectwerkz-plugin-1.2   maven-caller-plugin-1.1   maven-castor-plugin-1.2   maven-changelog-plugin-1.7.1   maven-changes-plugin-1.5.1   maven-checkstyle-plugin-2.5   maven-clean-plugin-1.3   maven-clover-plugin-1.6   maven-console-plugin-1.1   maven-cruisecontrol-plugin-1.5   maven-dashboard-plugin-1.5   maven-developer-activity-plugin-1.5.1   maven-dist-plugin-1.6.1   maven-docbook-plugin-1.2   maven-ear-plugin-1.5   maven-eclipse-plugin-1.9   maven-ejb-plugin-1.5   maven-faq-plugin-1.4   maven-file-activity-plugin-1.5.1   maven-genapp-plugin-2.2   maven-gump-plugin-1.4   maven-hibernate-plugin-1.2   maven-html2xdoc-plugin-1.3.1   maven-idea-plugin-1.5   maven-j2ee-plugin-1.5.1   maven-jalopy-plugin-1.3.1   maven-jar-plugin-1.6.1   maven-java-plugin-1.4   maven-javacc-plugin-1.1   maven-javadoc-plugin-1.7   maven-jboss-plugin-1.5   maven-jbuilder-plugin-1.5   maven-jcoverage-plugin-1.0.9   maven-jdee-plugin-1.1   maven-jdepend-plugin-1.5   maven-jdeveloper-plugin-1.4   maven-jdiff-plugin-1.4   maven-jellydoc-plugin-1.3.1   maven-jetty-plugin-1.1   maven-jira-plugin-1.1.2   maven-jnlp-plugin-1.4.1   maven-junit-doclet-plugin-1.2   maven-junit-report-plugin-1.5   maven-jxr-plugin-1.4.2   maven-latex-plugin-1.4.1   maven-latka-plugin-1.4.1   maven-license-plugin-1.2   maven-linkcheck-plugin-1.3.3   maven-multichanges-plugin-1.1   maven-multiproject-plugin-1.3.1   maven-native-plugin-1.1   maven-nsis-plugin-1.1   maven-pdf-plugin-2.2.1   maven-plugin-plugin-1.5.2   maven-pmd-plugin-1.6   maven-pom-plugin-1.4.1   maven-rar-plugin-1.0   maven-release-plugin-1.4.1   maven-repository-plugin-1.2   maven-scm-plugin-1.4.1   maven-shell-plugin-1.1   maven-simian-plugin-1.4   maven-site-plugin-1.5.2   maven-struts-plugin-1.3   maven-tasklist-plugin-2.3   maven-test-plugin-1.6.2   maven-tjdo-plugin-1.0.0   maven-uberjar-plugin-1.2   maven-vdoclet-plugin-1.2   maven-war-plugin-1.6.1   maven-webserver-plugin-2.0   maven-wizard-plugin-1.1   maven-xdoc-plugin-1.8 Home Build properties: {maven.build.dir=/home/tminor/maven/build/${pom.groupID}/${pom.artifactId}, build.view.path=/mms, maven.home.local=/home/tminor/maven/localhome}

Number of attachments :
0

Description

My pop extends an other pom.
<extend>../../project-defaults.xml</extend>
In that directory, there exists a project.properties.

This property file defines a company local, remote repository.

maven.repo.remote= http://maven.<company-domain>/repo

Using maven 1.0, this repository is used.
When using 1.0.1, it is not used.

Issue Links

This issue is duplicated by:
MAVEN-1513	maven.username is not inherited properly
MAVEN-1523	NoSuchFieldError
MAVEN-1509	Property "maven.home.local" doesn't get overriden
MAVEN-1519	Property maven.build.dir is no longer overridable in parent project

Activity

Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order

Hide

Permalink

Brett Porter added a comment - 12/Nov/04 5:28 PM

this is a regression resulting from fixing >1 level of inheritence. It only fails for build in properties (most importantly, maven.repo.remote).

Show

Brett Porter added a comment - 12/Nov/04 5:28 PM this is a regression resulting from fixing >1 level of inheritence. It only fails for build in properties (most importantly, maven.repo.remote).

Hide

Permalink

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 16/Nov/04 11:06 AM

My project layout is as follows:

common-build
project.properties
project.xml
kernel-module
project.xml
extension-1
project.xml
extension-2
project.xml

The extensions of the kernel are developed independently and can thus not be stored under kernel-module. Each module has a project.xml which says:
<extend>${basedir}/../common-build/project.xml</extend>
The output of "maven -X" tells me that the project.properties are read but the values (like maven.username and maven.repo.remote) are not set.

For me this is not a minor bug, but a show stopper.

Show

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 16/Nov/04 11:06 AM My project layout is as follows: common-build project.properties project.xml kernel-module project.xml extension-1 project.xml extension-2 project.xml The extensions of the kernel are developed independently and can thus not be stored under kernel-module. Each module has a project.xml which says: <extend>${basedir}/../common-build/project.xml</extend> The output of "maven -X" tells me that the project.properties are read but the values (like maven.username and maven.repo.remote) are not set. For me this is not a minor bug, but a show stopper.

Hide

Permalink

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 22/Nov/04 3:57 AM

Bug's priority should be set to critical as it is in the duplicated bug #1513.

Show

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 22/Nov/04 3:57 AM Bug's priority should be set to critical as it is in the duplicated bug #1513.

Hide

Permalink

Brett Porter added a comment - 22/Nov/04 5:20 AM

major is fairer.

We tend to drive priority by "fix for" version.

Show

Brett Porter added a comment - 22/Nov/04 5:20 AM major is fairer. We tend to drive priority by "fix for" version.

Hide

Permalink

Carlos Sanchez added a comment - 27/Nov/04 6:19 PM

A workaround is passing the property in the command line, e.g.
maven -Dmaven.repo.remote=http://www.ibiblio.org/maven/,http://dist.codehaus.org/

This way it's available to subprojects

Show

Carlos Sanchez added a comment - 27/Nov/04 6:19 PM A workaround is passing the property in the command line, e.g. maven -Dmaven.repo.remote=http://www.ibiblio.org/maven/,http://dist.codehaus.org/ This way it's available to subprojects

Hide

Permalink

Brett Porter added a comment - 29/Nov/04 9:19 PM

From Dr Wes Munsil:
For me, adding this to my top-level project.properties file seemed to make everything happy again:

maven.property.inheritance=true

Show

Brett Porter added a comment - 29/Nov/04 9:19 PM From Dr Wes Munsil: For me, adding this to my top-level project.properties file seemed to make everything happy again: maven.property.inheritance=true

Hide

Permalink

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 30/Nov/04 5:13 AM

The workaround suggested by Wes Munsil does not work for me. I tried to set "maven.property.inheritance=true" at the following places

Inherited "project.properties"
Project specific "project.properties"
Command line
None of them solved the issue.

Show

Boris Boehlen added a comment - 30/Nov/04 5:13 AM The workaround suggested by Wes Munsil does not work for me. I tried to set "maven.property.inheritance=true" at the following places

Inherited "project.properties"
Project specific "project.properties"
Command line None of them solved the issue.

Hide

Permalink

Brett Porter added a comment - 02/Dec/04 9:24 PM

looking at the code made this fairly obvious what was going wrong. I have it fixed, and will commit this evening.

Show

Brett Porter added a comment - 02/Dec/04 9:24 PM looking at the code made this fairly obvious what was going wrong. I have it fixed, and will commit this evening.

People

Assignee:

Brett Porter

Reporter:

Thomas Minor

Vote (2)

Watch (1)

Dates

Created:

12/Nov/04 10:49 AM

Updated:

08/Mar/06 10:45 PM

Resolved:

03/Dec/04 4:11 PM

Maven 1

maven seems not to evaluate .properties of parent pom

Details

Description

Issue Links

Activity

People

Dates