Problems with inner enum

I am having a similar problem with version 1.7.5

I tried responding to your email. I tried send you some screen shots that would provide you the information that you requested but it got bounced saying you are over quota which I guess means your mail box is full. Any how, I am running version v1.7.5.xx-20100926-200-e36-RC1 of the groovy compile which was installed when I installed the Eclipse Groovy plugin from http://dist.springsource.org/milestone/GRECLIPSE/e3.6/ and which also installed the groovy-all-1.7.5.jar.

The following test has been running successfully ever since I fixed GROOVY-3483. I still verified on 1.7.5 and it works fine. The same can also be seen at http://groovyconsole.appspot.com/script/252001 (1.8.0-beta-2)

You need to check more at your end. I suggest first you check the output of GroovySystem.version in the same environment where you get this issue. Tell me what version are you on.

package familie

class Mother3483 {
    Mother3483.Child child
    
    enum Child{
        Franz,
        Ferdi,
        Nand
    }
}

def mother = new Mother3483(child: Mother3483.Child.Franz)

assert mother.child as String == 'Franz'

I tried responding to your email. I tried send you some screen shots that would provide you the information that you requested but it got bounced saying you are over quota which I guess means your mail box is full. Any how, I am running version v1.7.5.xx-20100926-200-e36-RC1 of the groovy compile which was installed when I installed the Eclipse Groovy plugin from http://dist.springsource.org/milestone/GRECLIPSE/e3.6/ and which also installed the groovy-all-1.7.5.jar.

Please see my previous comment added to the ticket

Did you execute GroovySystem.version in that environment? What was the output?

I think you should try it outside GRECLIPSE - sometimes the behavior differs there and if that is the case, it needs to be highlighted to GRECLIPSE team.

Will it be possible for you to try it in a standalone groovyconsole of 1.7.5?

BTW, my which ID said that the quota is full - @gmail.com or @codehaus.org?

This shows the groovy jar on my classpath

I moved it from Groovy to GRECLIPSE, because I think this is a problem related to the plugin... If that is not true, please move back

Just saw the screenshots you attached. This is something totally different from the issue you have cloned (GROOVY-3483)

I think Guillaume has already highlighted this to GRECLIPSE team. See here: http://tinyurl.com/23nhnm7

Since at this point it looks like a GRECLIPSE issue (because it works fine in groovy standalone), I am un-assigning it from my name.

Will be happy to help if any help is needed from Groovy side.

As I mentioned on the mailing list, this is likely a duplicate of http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/GRECLIPSE-633 for which I've never had a reliable testcase, hopefully this is one (I'll try it in a moment). I am slightly confused however as the initial comment in this bug says the error is:

unable to resolve class Mother.Child

but in attached screenshot the error highlighted is as per GRECLIPSE-633:

Can't have an abstract method in a non-abstract class

Hi Andy,

I cloned the original issue so that is maybe what is confusing. How can I help? I don't have much to offer as far as a test case is concerned but if you are using Eclipse 3.6 SR1 and install the plugin from http://dist.springsource.org/milestone/GRECLIPSE/e3.6/ as well as the Google App Engine plugin you will have the exact environment that I have which I am running on Windows Vista with all patches applied.

Please let me know if there is anything I can do to assist.

Jeff

PS I can not email you directly because your in box must be full. I get the following bounced mail message:

Hi. This is the qmail-send program at mail.codehaus.org.
I'm afraid I wasn't able to deliver your message to the following addresses.
This is a permanent error; I've given up. Sorry it didn't work out.

<jira@codehaus.org>:
user is over quota

I forgot to include that I am also using gaelyk as my framework if that matters but it isn't anything that is installed into Eclipse but it is on the classpath.

I just tried the sample program from above on Eclipse 3.6.1 with the recent greclipse build and it compiled and ran fine (with the package statement). I haven't yet installed the app engine stuff, hard to see how that would be involved as my test project is just a groovy project with that one bit of code in.

The best thing to do, if you can, is to zip up the minimal failing project and email it to me at aclement AT vmware.com - that would be really helpful. I am 100% sure there is an issue here but if I can't recreate it, it will be very hard to address. Maybe there is something else about the project configuration interfering.

I am also on Windows7 (64bit) which is a difference, but if I could get hold of the failing project that would be a big help.

I emailed you earlier with some new information that I thought might be helpful. I hope it arrived in your inbox.

To recap, it appears that when I open a workspace containing only my project I don't get the bogus compiler errors but when I open a workspace with multiple projects I do get the errors. As I mentioned in my email, maybe it has something to do with the meta data associated with a workspace and which is used by the plugin system.

yep, i got your example code. I am travelling right now and plan to look at it as soon as I can

resurrecting this to look into it. Jeff have you still been hitting this? Many things have changed since this was last progressed. I double checked my inbox and found the projects you sent me, I tried them again and they are still behaving for me (I think they always were). I think we left it with me agreeing to do a debug build for you, which unfortunately I didn't get to, but i can do that now if we still think there is something to investigate here.

Well, just tried this one and can't reproduce. Since it's been several years since the last response, assuming that it's no longer a problem. But, please comment or reopen if you still see this.